Gallande Structuring Score
Gallande Partners independent scoring framework to evaluate and compare structured products using objective, weighted, and reproducible criteria.
100
Max. score
70%
Pricing
10%
Issuer
10%
Pre-Trade
10%
Post-Trade
In one sentence: The Gallande Structuring Score (GSS) is a proprietary 0-to-100 scoring framework that evaluates structured products across four weighted pillars: Pricing Competitiveness (70%), Issuer Credit Quality (10%), Pre-Trade Service (10%), and Post-Trade Service (10%).
Direct Answer
What is the Gallande Structuring Score?
The GSS is a 0-100 scoring system comparing structured products across four weighted pillars: Pricing Competitiveness (70%), Issuer Credit Quality (10%), Pre-Trade Service (10%), Post-Trade Service (10%). A score of 75+ indicates products suitable for institutional mandates.
Key Facts
Institutional Definition
The Gallande Structuring Score (GSS) is a proprietary quantitative analysis tool that enables Gallande Partners to evaluate, compare, and document the quality of a structured product at issuance. Centered on pricing competitiveness (70% of the score), the GSS reflects the fundamental economic reality of structured products: the value created or destroyed for the investor is primarily determined by the margin embedded in the issuance price. This framework is systematically used by Gallande Partners in its independent advisory process and forms the documentary basis of recommendations to wealth managers.
The 4 Framework Pillars
Pricing Competitiveness
Definition
Measures the gap between the theoretical fair value of the product (independently modeled) and the price offered by the issuer. A high score indicates a low issuer margin and a technically attractive product.
Evaluation Criteria
- Fair value calculated by proprietary model (Monte Carlo, Black-Scholes)
- Comparison with at least 3 competing issuers
- Secondary market bid/offer spread analysis
- Cost decomposition: zero-coupon bond + option budget + margin
Business Rationale
Pricing is the only objectively measurable criterion before issuance. For two structurally identical products, a 1% notional differential represents a direct loss for the investor. Pricing competitiveness is therefore the primary value creation lever for the end client.
Issuer Credit Quality
Definition
Assesses the financial soundness of the issuing bank. Since a structured product is an unsecured bank obligation, the issuer's credit quality constitutes the residual counterparty risk beyond capital protection.
Evaluation Criteria
- Long-term rating (Moody's, S&P, Fitch)
- CET1 ratio and balance sheet strength (tier 1 capital)
- History of restructuring or public bailout
Business Rationale
For capital-protected products, issuer quality is the dominant risk. For autocalls, it is secondary but non-negligible. The 10% weighting reflects the relative importance of this criterion within the overall score.
Pre-Trade Service
Definition
Assesses the quality of support provided by the issuer before the transaction: responsiveness, accuracy of indicative terms, availability of regulatory documentation (PRIIPs KID), and quality of structuring support.
Evaluation Criteria
- Response time to pricing requests
- Accuracy of indicative vs definitive terms
- Availability and quality of the PRIIPs KID
- Technical structuring support (simulations, scenarios)
Business Rationale
A rigorous pre-trade process reduces execution error risk and ensures regulatory compliance. Pre-trade service quality is an indicator of the issuer's operational reliability.
Post-Trade Service
Definition
Measures the quality of follow-up provided by the issuer during the product's life: valuation transparency, secondary liquidity, proactive communication on barrier events, and corporate action support.
Evaluation Criteria
- Frequency and transparency of daily valuations
- Secondary market bid/offer spread
- Proactive alerts on barrier proximity events
- Corporate action treatment (dividends, spin-offs)
Business Rationale
Post-trade quality determines the manager's ability to manage the product in their portfolio. Tight secondary liquidity is a direct cost if early exit is required.
Why Pricing Is Central
Economic Reality
On a €100,000 autocall with a 2% vs 1% issuer margin, the difference is €1,000 immediate theoretical value. Over 5 years, the compounded impact is significant on net portfolio performance.
Market Asymmetry
Issuer margins range from 0.5% to 3.5% of notional for comparable products. Without independent analysis, an investor cannot determine whether the proposed price is competitive.
GSS founding principle: "Two structured products with the same barriers, the same underlying, and the same maturity can differ by 2 to 3% in theoretical value solely due to issuer margin. Any evaluation that does not start with pricing starts with an error."
Concrete Scoring Example
Product analyzed
5-year autocall on Euro Stoxx 50, 9% p.a. coupon, -45% capital barrier
| Pillar | Observed Elements | Raw Score | Weighted Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing Competitiveness (70%) | Issuer margin: 1.2% vs market average 1.8%. Fair value: 98.8% | 82/100 | 57.4 |
| Issuer Credit Quality (10%) | A+ rating, 5Y CDS at 65bps, CET1 14.2% | 88/100 | 8.8 |
| Pre-Trade Service (10%) | Response in 1h45, PRIIPs KID available D+0, 3 scenarios provided | 78/100 | 7.8 |
| Post-Trade Service (10%) | Daily valuation, 0.9% secondary spread, active barrier alerts | 85/100 | 8.5 |
| FINAL SCORE | 82.5 / 100 | ||
Score Interpretation
Score 82.5/100 - Competitive product. Issuer margin below market average. High-quality issuer. Recommended for a yield enhancement mandate.
Interpretation Scale
Global Weighting Table
| Pillar | Weight | Max. weighted score | Calculation method |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing Competitiveness | 70% | 70 pts | Multi-issuer comparison + proprietary fair value model |
| Issuer Credit Quality | 10% | 10 pts | Rating + 5Y CDS + CET1 ratio |
| Pre-Trade Service | 10% | 10 pts | Responsiveness + term accuracy + documentation |
| Post-Trade Service | 10% | 10 pts | Valuation + secondary liquidity + alerts |
| Total | 100% | 100 pts | Final weighted score |
Key Takeaways
- The GSS is Gallande Partners' reference framework for comparing structured products across issuers
- Pricing accounts for 70% of the score as it is the only objectively measurable criterion before issuance
- A score of 75+ indicates a product suitable for standard institutional mandates
- The framework is applicable to all types of structured products (autocall, Phoenix, capital-protected)
- Gallande Partners uses the GSS to document and justify every recommendation
- The model is independent: Gallande Partners receives no remuneration from issuers
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Content
Get a Gallande Structuring Score for your mandate
Gallande Partners performs an independent scoring analysis on every structured product selected for its clients. Contact us for an initial discussion.
Schedule a consultation